Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Threshold Pot doesn't work
Collapse
X
-
I have no idea what kind of amplifier you need or how much gain or anything else. You really need to build the extra demod stage and see what the "iron signal" looks like before you try to figure out what to do with it. I'm pretty sure you will not be able to design a complete circuit, build it, and have it work on the first try. Build it a little at a time, and figure out the next steps as you go.
-
Thank you.Originally posted by Carl-NC View Post#524, not #522.
I had a review about the schematic, i think you right.
The DISC demod is motion and we do not need a LM393.
So, i decided to remove it and add a single simple amplifier stage with a gain pot for Iron sensitivity.
I have a similar request, is it possible to see the following schematic and check its errors?
1- For example, do you think it is better to use inverting or non-inverting amplifier?
2- Do you have any suggestion for gain of the stage (R55 and R56 values)?
3-Is the 4.7K, 100K and diode before 2n3904 correct?
Off course, i am going to test both models LM393 and the single stage.
Thank you for your supporting.Last edited by h9361; 11-30-2025, 05:39 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
Thank you.Originally posted by Carl-NC View PostThe data sheet tells you how the comparator works:
"The output consists of an open drain NPN (pull-down or low side) transistor. The output NPN sinks current when the negative input voltage is higher than the positive input voltage and the offset voltage."
Probably you will need a series diode on the base of the 3904.
Do you think the added diode to base of 3904 at post 522 is correct or the following (diode + 1k resistor is true?
Attached Files
Leave a comment:
-
The data sheet tells you how the comparator works:
"The output consists of an open drain NPN (pull-down or low side) transistor. The output NPN sinks current when the negative input voltage is higher than the positive input voltage and the offset voltage."
Probably you will need a series diode on the base of the 3904.
Leave a comment:
-
Thank you.Originally posted by Carl-NC View Post220 is probably a good place to start.
I added a pull-up resistor on the open-collector comparator outputs to +5 so the comparator output will be -5V or +5V.
Please see schematic #518 post. As you see, the LM393 has two inputs (DISC and GB channel demod).
Can you tell me LM393 output voltage if the two inputs are high? +5 or -5?!
In fact, the 2n3904 must act only both input of LM393 are high. So, i do know which of +5 or -5 is considered as high for its final out.
Do you think it is need to add the diode before 2n3904 (follows)?
Attached FilesLast edited by h9361; 11-29-2025, 04:19 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
Thank you. I will test in real.Originally posted by Carl-NC View PostI don't know, you may need to add resistors and clamp diodes. This is a very experimental circuit, you will need to build it and see what it needs.
As you know, HHD ( more other PI) uses a gain 1000 for preamp.
I also used for my HHD+GB ( previous version for GB) with a gain 1000.
About this version (post #518, can you suggest me a good gain for this GB method?
In this schematic (post #518, gain is 220 (220K/1K).
Thank you
Leave a comment:
-
I don't know, you may need to add resistors and clamp diodes. This is a very experimental circuit, you will need to build it and see what it needs.
Leave a comment:
-
Thank you dear Carl.Originally posted by Carl-NC View PostYes, you can directly clamp with the LM393 but it needs to be powered from +5V/0V instead of +5V/-5V.
Yes, a JFET switch can be used. I prefer to place the S on the ground node but in reality most JFETs have interchangeable D and S.
I set power of LM393 to +5 and 0 ( in my schematic, ground is +VB like HHD).
Since all channels are set by +5 and -5, do you think the ground (+VB) is OK for my schematic?
Leave a comment:
-
Yes, you can directly clamp with the LM393 but it needs to be powered from +5V/0V instead of +5V/-5V.
Yes, a JFET switch can be used. I prefer to place the S on the ground node but in reality most JFETs have interchangeable D and S.
Leave a comment:
-
I do not know how i can thank you for your helping.Originally posted by Carl-NC View PostIf you use a DD coil then the waveform at TP4 will look like those in post 512. The TX-on and TX-off are clearly labeled. You will need to determine where to sample with S5. Inverting or non-inverting preamp does not matter, you can design the other circuitry for either polarity. The LM393 has an open-collector output (see the data sheet) so it can directly clamp the audio without using an extra NPN.
Please see attached, the LM393 connection to my Audio for blank, is it true?
About the added demod, do you think i can use BF256A or BF255A or BF245A instead of 4066 ( shown in following picture)?
If yes, Do you think the pins are true?
Please forgive me. I will make its PCB and do test.
I will notify my result here.
Thank youLast edited by h9361; 11-28-2025, 09:55 AM.
Leave a comment:
-
If you use a DD coil then the waveform at TP4 will look like those in post 512. The TX-on and TX-off are clearly labeled. You will need to determine where to sample with S5. Inverting or non-inverting preamp does not matter, you can design the other circuitry for either polarity. The LM393 has an open-collector output (see the data sheet) so it can directly clamp the audio without using an extra NPN.
Leave a comment:
-
I think you used an Inverting preamp. So, Iron shows itself as increasing.Originally posted by Carl-NC View Post
About my schematic ( one that you added another demod), you connected it to PI preamp that is non-inverting.
So i think Iron shows itself as reverse via decreasing.
Leave a comment:
-
Thank you dear carl for your complete information.Originally posted by Carl-NC View Post
Please consider tp4 form scope in HHD, can you show me which point is TX on? Is the DISC sample (S5) true from preamp output ?
I want to build the above schematic with lm393 comparing but do you think i can connect its out to the 2n3904 that you added for blank audio?
I think out of the lm393 is -5V.Last edited by h9361; 11-27-2025, 12:37 PM.
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: