[QUOTE=BillNEWAST;147106]bkline, what is the difference between the floppy/hdd cable an the stock item minelab puts on. I can't see any difference in the amount of copper in the two. I think that minelab just used that type of cable because they got a GOOD Deal on it and it did the job adequitley. I think that is like the Battery system they used. At the time that was the Best Off The Shelf system to use. It had Nothing to do with "WAS It the Best".
.QUOTE]
Hi Bill,
I used the twinlead from power adapters I work with at work. This uses 22AWG wire (IDE uses 28-30AWG). It is a close fit to the hole. It is easy to strip - really easy to do it without accidentally cutting some of the stranded wires. I cleaned the holes up really well and then stripped the wire ends like and eighth of an inch or so and inserted them into the holes without tinning them. When I tried tinning them I found that sometimes solder would exceed the hole size. So once inserting them succesfully in the holes I put a dab of rosin on each and soldered them. Trimmed em up and then cleaned off the rosin residue. I work at Western Digital so I have a bunch of old IDE cables I could have used. I'm not saying they won't work but here's another point: when you use a ribbon cable it is easy if not careful (like me) to put stress on the end wires when you insert or remove the boards from the extrusion by pushing one then the other. With the twinleads, each pair is separate so you can get away with it without risk of breaking wires. So they may be ok if you strip them back into pairs for the first 1/2"-1" each end. The original Minelab ribbons are just an accident waiting to happen as opening the two boards apart or pushing one pcb in then the other is likely to cause breakage of the stranded wires. I suppose if there were silicone at the attach point it would help prevent this. My experience with IDE cable ribbon is that it is difficult to do all 20 strippings necessary without screwing up and cutting some strands of some. Then inserting all 10 at a time vs my 2 is another challenge. I wouldn't advise anyone to mess with the ribbons unless they determine there is an intermittant or broken wire. Just be thoughtful about the hazards of pcb manipulation. There could be signal quality issues involved too that made Minelab chose the ribbons they did - mine may be inappropriate and thinner wire better. Just don't know because I don't know the schematic of the cables.
.QUOTE]
Hi Bill,
I used the twinlead from power adapters I work with at work. This uses 22AWG wire (IDE uses 28-30AWG). It is a close fit to the hole. It is easy to strip - really easy to do it without accidentally cutting some of the stranded wires. I cleaned the holes up really well and then stripped the wire ends like and eighth of an inch or so and inserted them into the holes without tinning them. When I tried tinning them I found that sometimes solder would exceed the hole size. So once inserting them succesfully in the holes I put a dab of rosin on each and soldered them. Trimmed em up and then cleaned off the rosin residue. I work at Western Digital so I have a bunch of old IDE cables I could have used. I'm not saying they won't work but here's another point: when you use a ribbon cable it is easy if not careful (like me) to put stress on the end wires when you insert or remove the boards from the extrusion by pushing one then the other. With the twinleads, each pair is separate so you can get away with it without risk of breaking wires. So they may be ok if you strip them back into pairs for the first 1/2"-1" each end. The original Minelab ribbons are just an accident waiting to happen as opening the two boards apart or pushing one pcb in then the other is likely to cause breakage of the stranded wires. I suppose if there were silicone at the attach point it would help prevent this. My experience with IDE cable ribbon is that it is difficult to do all 20 strippings necessary without screwing up and cutting some strands of some. Then inserting all 10 at a time vs my 2 is another challenge. I wouldn't advise anyone to mess with the ribbons unless they determine there is an intermittant or broken wire. Just be thoughtful about the hazards of pcb manipulation. There could be signal quality issues involved too that made Minelab chose the ribbons they did - mine may be inappropriate and thinner wire better. Just don't know because I don't know the schematic of the cables.
Comment